Although these two boots share a lot of the same style and materials, there are still quite a few differences which might not be obvious from the pictures below.
Below are the overall specs, and then below a quick but deeper comparison for you to check out (just scroll on down :>).
-25° F / -32° C
-25° F / -32° C
Waterproof suede leather
Faux fur cuff
Fully waterproof waxed canvas
Faux fur cuff
Midsole: 2.5 mm bonded felt frost plug
Outer: Handcrafted waterproof vulcanized rubber shell with herringbone outsole
Footbed: Molded EVA
Outer: Moulded Rubber
Removable 6 mm recycled felt inner boot
Full-length fleece lining with 100 grams of fixed insulation
The Joan of Arctic is similar to a classic Sorel Caribou with the rubber lower section, the big laces and lace hooks up the front. But, it also has a big faux fur top to the suede leather, adding that little extra flair.
The Tofino is similar to a degree, but has a little less fur overflow on the top, and a criss-cross pattern on the waterproof canvas material. The newer model, the Tofino II has a more diagonal/interwoven cross which is in the picture on the right (you can click that image to see more models on Amazon).
The Tofino also comes in a few more fun colors like bright red, which the Joan of Arctic does not have.
Note: Although there is a Knit model (of the Joan of Arctic) which you can see to the right, which comes in pink, green and beige. This has a knitted finish at the top instead of the faux fur.
When you are wearing boots around all day they can become quite tiring to wear, if they are super-heavy like the Caribous from Sorel.
That is why it is nice to know that both the Tofino and Joan are quite light at 1.94 (Joan) and 1.34 (Tofino). So, the Tofino is nice and light mainly because of the canvas instead of leather on the upper.
No big difference worth mentioning here. They both come with a durable rubber sole designed to cope with winter conditions.
There are some models that vary with the Sorels, but the "average" Joan of Arctic vs Tofino is pretty close.
The Joan of Arctics come up an extra half inch on the calves, which is either good or bad depending on how long your legs are and how deep the snow is you will be wading through. Just keep in mind these are not snow hiking boots :>
The lining on these two boots is a little different, and I have been unable to figure out exactly (material-wise) how that makes a difference. But let's just say they are both rated to -25 F/ -32 C, so they should be nice and toasty for most people walking around for shorter periods in sub-zero temperatures. Which, if we are honest, is the main thing people use them for (quick errand to the shops etc).
Roger is a little obsessed with travel. He has been to over 40 countries, broken 3 suitcases and owned over 10 backpacks in 12 months. What he doesn't know about travel, ain't worth knowing!