The Osprey team produces great quality packs that are hard to choose between. And in this review, I am going to cover the Porter 46 vs Farpoint 40, two of the best travel daypacks on the market. They are both convertible carry on bags, that are great for weekend trips or just as hand luggage. Although they are quite similar, there are some fundamental differences. This is actually great news because it helps us make a choice!
I know which one I love, but it’s not about me – it’s about what is best for your travels.
Do you need more space? More pockets?
Do you have more electronics?
Or do you prefer a more sturdy backpack?
All this will become clear!
|SEE ON AMAZON →|
|SEE ON AMAZON →|
The Osprey Porter 46 is a very handy travel bag, especially for those wanting to take lots of electronics and fit in a lot of gear.
The inner storage area is very deep & wide and can fit a lot of your gear in it.
It will definitely be a great choice for weekend trips or people just wanting to have a lot of stuff with them (jacket, shoes, toiletry and more! Yes, it’s big).
And it comes with compression straps on the front to help keep the size down for carry-on. Something we all love (not having to check in your bags!).
Or, if you aren’t carrying much (or storing it) you can compress it way down and make it a lot smaller.
In general, it sounds like an awesome pack, but will it still look like that when we get down to the details? Let’s find out!
The Osprey Porter comes with a lot of padded carry handles (top, side, bottom), maybe too many. But they do come in handy once in a while, especially when you are not using this as a backpack. (picture trying to grab it out of the overhead bins on a plane).
Waist straps are stored in the bottom, and they can be tucked away for flights and used again once you land (if you check the luggage in).
Just keep in mind that the hip belt is not super-padded so although it’s great for travel, it might not do the job if you intend on doing long day hikes or carrying heavy loads. But for most travelers, it will be more than enough.
The main electronics storage area of the Osprey Porter is on the back panel, which is a design improvement as compared to last year’s model. This way your electronics will be much safer, as there is no way that someone could actually get to that compartment while you are carrying the backpack.
This will also be very handy when you have to get all your gear out for security checks at the airport. It’s very spacious, fitting a reasonably large laptop (like a 13″ Mac) as well as having a nice pocket behind that for other gear (Kindle, iPad etc).
And there is also space for a phone, diary, mouse, cables, chargers etc. All in all a well thought out.
Yes, the main compartment of the Porter is pretty large, and you can pack a ton of stuff in it. And you have a dedicated compartment for all your favorite electronics. But, what else does the Porter have to offer, and can it really convince you that it is better than the Farpoint?
For one thing, the front compartment (which used to be the laptop compartment) now features an organizational panel, and it has lockable zippers. And the compartment is still pretty spacious, so you could definitely pack all your in-cabin necessities inside it, and have them all handy during the flight. All of that without ever having to open up the main compartment and mess up your packing efforts.
The new Porter 46 also features a zippered top pocket, so that it’s even easier for you to stay organized. From the top of my head, it’s a great compartment for your toiletries or any liquids that might accidentally get spilled in the main compartment (if you’re as unlucky as I am). And it’s so far away from the electronics compartment that there’s no way a drop would ever get to your precious laptop.
We’ve established that the Porter 46 will allow you to pack plenty of items, and organize them all just how you like. Notice I said plenty of items there – 46 liters is a lot of storage space, and you are bound to feel the weight of the pack when you have to carry it around for a few hours. So, what can you expect, in terms of your own carrying comfort?
For one thing, the back panel is padded, so there shouldn’t be any items from inside the pack that is poking you in the bag. However, it’s not ventilated, which is a big downside in my opinion. Just imagine walking around in the middle of August with this beast on your back – you are bound to begin sweating bullets after about half an hour.
The shoulders straps, on the other hand, are padded and ventilated, so there’s that. They also come with a sternum strap that doubles as an emergency whistle – perfect for all of us who couldn’t whistle to save our life. And the job of the sternum strap is to keep both of the shoulder straps in place so that one of them can’t just slip off.
I mentioned already that there’s a lightly padded hip belt, but I didn’t tell you what its main purpose was. Well, it has to do with your carrying comfort; a hip belt helps distribute the weight of the pack across your entire torso so that your shoulders aren’t the only ones carrying the load. That means that the pack won’t feel too heavy on your back and that you should stay reasonably comfortable even when it’s fully packed.
Overall, it looks like a very comfy backpack – especially for its size. And the shoulder straps and the harness can be stored away in their separate compartment, for when you want to put the Porter in the overhead compartment, or trunk of your car or whatever – the point is that you hide them so that they won’t get caught on anything.
Note: There is a specific women’s version of the Farpoint called the Fairview (see a detailed review here)
So, you have all your electronics and small stuff sorted on the front, but how much space do you get inside?
This pack is big! In fact, most of the area below the front panel is an open storage compartment that is very deep.
There are also two zippered pockets running the length of each side for more of your smaller stuff, or just to double as a laundry bag.
And with the compression straps I mentioned earlier, it’s easy to cinch down your load once the panel is closed and you are ready for travel. Just keep in mind, this area is harder to access (like a suitcase) so you will want your travel documents, electronics, etc all in the front panel while you are traveling.
The Osprey Farpoint 40 is a great travel backpack for use as a carry-on.
Again, it is a convertible backpack, carry on where the straps can be zipped away in the back. Great for travel!
Osprey quality is always there with top-end material, handles, zippers, and mesh. Something that I love to see in a pack that I am investing in.
But, when we look at all of its features and compare them to the Porter, will it come out on top? Let’s see.
Naturally, there are two shoulder straps on the Farpoint, and they are padded and highly adjustable. This will make it easy for everyone to make them fit their body perfectly. Fun fact; you will know that the backpack fits you well if there is no space between the back panel or the shoulders straps and your body.
There is also a handy shoulder carry strap included, which you can attach (or leave at home) if you want more options to carry it.
On the front, there are also compression straps which always come in handy to reduce space when you don’t fully pack the Farpoint. And they also help ensure that all of your stuff stays in place and doesn’t wiggle around the pack when you’re carrying it.
In addition to that, there is also a sternum strap (as there should be), as well as a waist belt. In this aspect, the Farpoint is pretty much the same as the Porter.
Just like the Porter, the Farpoint 40 also has a padded sleeve for your laptop. The main difference is that the sleeve on the Farpoint is inside the main compartment, so I think the Porter has an advantage here.
That’s because the sleeve on this pack takes away from the overall capacity of the main compartment. So, you can pack even fewer things in it. But the good news is that there is also a padded compartment for your tablet, so at least you know that all of your electronics will be safe.
In the end, it all depends on how you travel. And how you store stuff in your bag.
I like to use a solid backpack with straps that are comfortable on my back and I can carry for a long time (and double as a day hike pack). So for me, it is the Farpoint. It also has more than enough space, straps, pockets, and room for both a large laptop and kindle/tablet.
Oh, and don’t forget that Osprey released a women’s fit version of the Farpoint, called the Fairview which you can check out here.
But, if you need more organizational space (pockets for your phone, diary, cables, internal pockets) then the Porter is far better. It also has more space which is a good thing as you can bring more (or a bad thing – as you have to carry it, with less back-friendly straps). So this bag is more for the person who does not carry your gear far (ie. you just need to carry it at the airport, taxi, etc).
I honestly don’t think you can go wrong with either of them but have a good look at the videos and points in the pros and cons, and then see what fits your travel style!
Some people prefer the Porter 30 to the Porter 46 because the 46L size is just too big for carry-on.
All of the above areas of review are the same for the Porter 30 vs the Porter 46, it is just the size that differs. There is obviously less packing space and the laptop sleeve is a tighter squeeze for a 15 inch, but it still fits.
Technically the sizes are:
Porter 30: 19.7 x 12.6 x 9 inches / 50 x 32 x 23 cm
Porter 46: 21 x 14 x 14.5 inches / 55 x 36 x 23 cm
Of course, the Porter 30 is also verging on too big for carry on, but with the slightly smaller size of the pack, it is easier to compress down to an acceptable size. The Porter 46L can too, but it is a tougher problem because it is just a lot bigger.